Skip to main content


Dec. 16, 2019: New findings published today in Nature Communications show that the Zika virus epidemic in Latin America likely suppressed the incidence of dengue in subsequent years to aberrantly low levels. Then, dengue came roaring back.


When the Zika epidemic burned through the Americas in 2015, it was transmitted in the same areas where dengue virus was already endemic. This was not unexpected, as both viruses are genetically and antigenically similar, and they also share the same mosquito vectors, Aedes aegypti and Aedes albopictus.

But what was surprising was how quickly dengue virus faded into the background in the immediate years following the Zika outbreak. New findings from researchers at the University of Florida’s Emerging Pathogens Institute and UF’s College of Liberal Arts and Sciences Department of Biology, describes how dengue was likely suppressed to abnormally low levels in Latin America in the years following the Zika epidemic. Their work explains a possible mechanism for how dengue then came roaring back in 2019.

The study, which published today in Nature Communications, was led by Rebecca Borchering while she was a postdoctoral researcher in biology at UF. It was conducted by multiple members of the Infectious Disease Dynamics lab which is led by the study’s senior author, Derek Cummings, who is a UF biology professor.

The researchers suspected that something about the immune response to Zika offered cross-protection against subsequent dengue infection. Prior work conducted by Cummings and collaborators, which published in Science, showed that individuals with dengue immunity were partially protected from the new Zika virus.

“In certain parts of Brazil, 60 to 70 percent of the population was infected with Zika within four or five months in 2015,” Borchering says. “The attack rate was extremely high. That was followed by reports in 2017 that Brazil was experiencing a very low incidence of dengue. We decided to test this more rigorously, to see if there was a relationship between Zika infection and subsequent dengue infections.”

Specifically, Cummings wondered, What if being infected with Zika offered immunity against dengue for a year or two? Temporary immunity is observed between dengue viruses so it would make sense that infection with the similar Zika virus might create the same temporary protection.

Using publicly available population-level data stretching from 1999-2017 for Brazil and from 2007-2017 for Colombia, Borchering and colleagues assembled models of dengue incidence. They used historic incidence rates of dengue to build models of dengue incidence and compare incidence in the years during and after the Zika outbreak to those before.

Borchering, now a postdoctoral research associate in the Odum School of Ecology at the University of Georgia, says their first major finding was to establish that statistically, 2017 was an aberrantly low year for dengue in Brazil and Colombia.

Following the Zika outbreak in 2015-2016, Brazil saw 252,054 dengue cases in 2017 and 265,930 in 2018. In strong contrast, 1.6 million cases were reported in 2015.

“Dengue naturally has cycles of high and low incidence years,” Borchering says. “But even given these cycles, the observed dengue incidence was statistically very different from what you would expect given past historic data.”

When there are low amounts of dengue in a population, that means immunity is not being produced, Cummings says. “It tends to mean that in future time periods, you will have more dengue,” he adds. “There is a feedback in the system that immunity suppresses further transmission, and if you have not had a lot of immunity accumulating in the past few years, then you might be waiting for a pretty sizeable outbreak.”

To test whether immunity produced in response to Zika infections that temporarily protects individuals from dengue could explain the decline in dengue seen after the Zika outbreak, the group built simulations of dengue and Zika transmission. They examined a wide range of simulations with multiple assumptions of interactions between dengue and Zika.


“We found that these low numbers of dengue incidence in 2017 and 2018 were best explained by the simulations that had varying levels of cross-immunity built into them,” says Angkana Huang, a UF doctoral student in biology who also worked on the study. “Which supports the line of thinking that cross-immunity from Zika infections works to suppress dengue transmission in the years following a Zika outbreak.”

The simulations also suggested that periods of reduced dengue could be followed by very large epidemics of dengue, once cross-protection waned and dengue resurged. This finding of the models has unfortunately been seen in real life; many countries of the Americas have experienced record numbers of dengue cases in 2019 including 1.9 million cases reported from Brazil.

There are some limitations to the data, Borchering cautioned. “Many early Zika cases may have been misdiagnosed as dengue, due to shared symptoms, or were not recorded, because it took time to identify that Zika virus was circulating and to establish reporting protocols,” Borchering says. Second, climatological factors and changes in surveillance may affect dengue incidence and could contribute to changes seen in the last few years.

Cummings says that research is needed at the level of individuals to see how Zika and dengue immunity may affect each other, and whether having had Zika was predictive of who has a dengue infection. He expects that dengue will begin to settle back down to normal after this year, as the perturbation of Zika entering the Americas as a novel pathogen settles down.

“The big question now is, when will Zika come back?” Cummings says. “Because it almost certainly will. What we don’t know is how long Zika immunity excludes new Zika outbreaks.”

EPI Explainer: The Four Faces of Dengue

Dengue virus has four different serotypes. Becoming infected with one serotype is thought to confer life-long, or at least long-lasting, immunity against that particular type. It also confers temporary immunity against the three other serotypes. However, after a few years, people are at increased risk of becoming severely ill if they become infected with a different serotype after their initial infection. Because Zika is a genetically similar virus to dengue, many researchers have hypothesized that immunity to Zika virus may follow a similar pattern to dengue and may confer temporary immunity to dengue infection for a year or two; but it may also possibly place people at risk after that time.


The work was conducted by researchers at UF (Rebecca Borchering, Angkana Huang, Diana Rojas, Leah Katzelnick, Silvio Martinez, Greg King, Stephanie Cinkovich and Derek Cummings), Johns Hopkins University  (Luis Mier-y-Teran-Romero, Justin Lessler), and the University of California-San Francisco (Isabel Rodriguez-Barraquer).

Creator Credits

Written by DeLene Beeland

Top photo: This is a digitally colorized transmission electron microscopic image of Zika virus, which is a member of the family, Flaviviridae. Virus particles, colored blue, are 40nm in diameter, with an outer envelope, and an inner dense coreand credits here

Chart: Figure 11 from the published paper, courtesy of the authors, shows the different assumptions programmed into various simulations. Panels I-L best match the "trough" in observed dengue cases following the Zika epidemic, when cross-immunity may have temporarily provided an unusually large degree of protection against dengue.


Read More

Read Derek Cummings, Ph.D. bio here.

Read Impacts of Zika emergence in Latin America on endemic dengue transmission here (open access).


后宫视频app下载安装 小奶猫app下载安装 探探直播app下载安装 蝶恋花直播下载app视频污版 黄瓜直播app下载安装 烟花巷直播ios免费下载 小蝌蚪下载app视频污版 盘她s直播app下载安装 香蕉直播ios免费下载 夜夜直播下载app视频污版 荔枝视频app下载安装 笔芯直播app下载安装 月色直播app下载安装 抖阴直播ios免费下载 幸福宝app下载安装 花姬直播app下载安装 享受直播app下载安装 盘她直播ios免费下载 成版人短视频app下载污 菠萝菠萝蜜视频ios免费下载 ML聚合直播app下载安装 骚虎直播app下载安装 JAV名优馆app下载污 iAVBOBOapp下载污 月光宝盒直播下载app视频污版 欢喜视频下载app视频污版 秀儿直播ios免费下载 柠檬直播app下载安装 微杏app下载安装 笔芯直播app下载安装 野花视频app下载安装 向日葵视频app下载安装 食色app下载安装 繁花直播ios免费下载 后宫ios免费下载 香草成视频人app下载污 铁牛ios免费下载 七秒鱼直播app下载安装 丝瓜ios免费下载 s8视频ios免费下载 大番号ios免费下载 iAVBOBOios免费下载 葫芦娃视频下载app视频污版 抖阴app下载安装 奶茶视频app下载安装 七秒鱼直播下载app视频污版 f2富二代app下载安装 91视频ios免费下载 小蝌蚪视频ios免费下载 A头条ios免费下载 月亮视频ios免费下载 樱花ios免费下载 美梦视频app下载污 swag视频app下载安装 7秒鱼ios免费下载 Kitty直播app下载安装 花心直播app下载安装 泡芙下载app视频污版 咪哒ios免费下载 食色短视频ios免费下载 小天仙直播app下载污 大番号app下载安装 快狐app下载污 七秒鱼直播下载app视频污版 骚虎直播ios免费下载 97豆奶视频app下载污 猛虎视频ios免费下载 爱爱视频app下载安装 豆奶抖音短视频app下载安装 小猪视频app下载安装 年华直播app下载污 小奶狗ios免费下载 尤蜜视频app下载安装 丝瓜视频污app下载安装 媚妹秀app下载安装 茶馆视频app下载安装 初见直播ios免费下载 小v视频app下载安装 91香蕉视频下载app视频污版 小怪兽ios免费下载 swag台湾app下载安装 七仙女直播ios免费下载 丝瓜视频ios免费下载 成版人抖音app下载安装 暗夜直播ios免费下载 盘他直播app下载安装 大西瓜视频ios免费下载 含羞草视频ios免费下载 榴莲视频下载app视频污版 富二代ios免费下载 樱花ios免费下载 鲍鱼视频ios免费下载 盘他直播app下载安装 水仙直播下载app视频污版 猛虎直播ios免费下载 繁花直播app下载安装 97豆奶视频app下载污 樱花直播下载app视频污版 左手视频app下载污 迷雾直播下载app视频污版 花姿直播下载app视频污版 lutubeapp下载污 千层浪ios免费下载 佳丽直播下载app视频污版 花狐狸直播app下载安装 猛虎直播app下载安装 蚪音ios免费下载 草榴短视频下载app视频污版 ML聚合app下载污 含羞草视频app下载安装 JOJO直播ios免费下载 水晶直播app下载安装 69视频app下载安装 荔枝app下载安装 梦幻直播下载app视频污版 黄色直播软件下载app视频污版